Indianapolis, the bustling capital of Indiana, boasts a diverse real estate landscape that ranges from historic homes to modern urban developments. Navigating this dynamic market requires expertise, and that’s where Indianapolis’ top real estate agents come in. Let’s explore the cream of the crop in the Circle City’s real estate scene.
1. Melanie Giglio – Compass
With over 22 years of residential real estate experience, Melanie Giglio has built a reputation for excellence and professionalism among clients and industry peers alike.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 357
- Average Price Point: $630K
- Years of Experience: 22
Melanie Giglio’s LinkedIn Profile
2. Scott Smith – Keller Williams Realty
Scott Smith leads a team that takes a different approach to real estate, combining leading-edge technology with experience and integrity.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 274
- Average Price Point: $250K
- Years of Experience: 16
Scott Smith’s LinkedIn Profile
3. Peter Stewart – The Peter Stewart Realty Group
Peter Stewart has been a driving force in the real estate industry since 2009, specializing in assisting clients with buying, selling, and investing in real estate.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 248
- Average Price Point: $260K
- Years of Experience: 15
Peter Stewart’s LinkedIn Profile
4. Jeffrey Cummings – RE/MAX Complete
Jeffrey Cummings, a licensed real estate broker with RE/MAX in Fishers, IN, has been helping clients buy and sell properties since 2007.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 212
- Average Price Point: $270K
- Years of Experience: 17
Jeffrey Cummings’ LinkedIn Profile
5. Derek Gutting – Keller Williams Realty
Derek Gutting’s extensive knowledge of the Indianapolis area has helped him become a local real estate leader, ranking in the top 0.5% of all local agents.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 158
- Average Price Point: $400K
- Years of Experience: 24
Derek Gutting’s LinkedIn Profile
6. Aaron Walker – Coldwell Banker
Aaron Walker’s passion for real estate spans 25 years, beginning with his first investment property during his early twenties.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 155
- Average Price Point: $230K
- Years of Experience: 9
Aaron Walker’s LinkedIn Profile
7. James Embry – Keller Williams Realty – Indy Metro North
James Embry specializes in making his clients happy, offering expertise for first-time buyers, those making lateral moves, or relocating.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 132
- Average Price Point: $400K
- Years of Experience: 22
James Embry’s LinkedIn Profile
8. Ivona Kutermankiewicz – Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Chicago
Ivona Kutermankiewicz entered the real estate profession shortly after moving to the United States in 1991 and has since built an impressive career.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 128
- Average Price Point: $810K
- Years of Experience: 33
Ivona Kutermankiewicz’s LinkedIn Profile
9. Jeffrey Proctor – @properties
Since 2003, Jeff Proctor has been working with buyers, sellers, and developments in a wide array of areas within Indianapolis, developing into one of the top agents in the area.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 98
- Average Price Point: $890K
- Years of Experience: 21
Jeffrey Proctor’s LinkedIn Profile
10. Cindy Stockhaus – Better Homes and Gardens Gold Key
With over 20 years of experience, Cindy Stockhaus has earned a reputation as a trusted and ethical expert in the field, consistently ranking as a top producer.
Key Stats:
- Home Transactions: 92
- Average Price Point: $330K
- Years of Experience: 22







