Tinder Horror Stories That Will Leave You Frightened This Halloween

Tinder is filled with all kinds of people. You could either match with someone you’re supposed to be with, match with a catfish, or match with someone that you regret. This Halloween at Social Catfish we wanted to bring you the scariest Tinder horror stories that will blow you away. From the strangest catfish stories to the weirdest first dates, we have all kinds of horror stories that we wanted to share with you this Halloween. We looked at the latest Tinder horror stories from Reddit to give you a Halloween article to remember. Keep scrolling to read the weirdest Tinder horror stories imaginable.

Tinder Horror Stories That Will Leave You Frightened This Halloween

Chocolate Milk and a Cigarette

From Reddit User Kaldenar: “This happened just after I decided to get into the dating scene after a traumatic end to a three-year relationship. So it’s 00:45 and a tinder match messages me asking what I’m doing, then invites me to go out with her. I think it’s a bit late, but the clubs are open for 3-4 more hours so why not? I should take opportunities, right? I’m a single man in his 20s for the first time. She says she’ll pick me up (Driving in towards the town from outside of it) and I put on cologne and a nice shirt, get ready to go out. I go to the car, my match is in the front passenger seat and her friend is driving. I think it’s pretty weird but having a friend along isn’t super off so I get in and ask which club we’re going to.

‘We’re not going out-out, just out.’ My match says as we drive off.

‘Where are we going?’ I ask, feeling a little uncomfortable.

‘Just into town,’ she replies.

They drive to a nearby bridge with a carpark under it and park, turn the radio up and start chatting. The Girl driving pulls out a 1L (2 pints) bottle of chocolate milk and starts drinking it, they talk about the most boring stuff, barely include me in conversation, and start rolling cigarettes. After 15 mins they get out of the car to have a smoke, I get out too. My tinder match is wearing Fluffy white slippers that light up with each step. I turn and face them, ‘I appreciate you guys picking me up but this really isn’t my scene, I’m going to head off, have a nice night.’ They were very offended.”

The Old Therapist

From Reddit User Rriro: “I went to his place and we hooked up but after he goes ‘so you wanna know what I’m really into?’ And I was like sure and then he grabs my foot. I have a really irrational fear of people touching my feet so I ran the hell out of there any way I get to the living room on the way out and it turns out to be his parents’ house and I look at his mother and see she was my old therapist.“

Revenge On Her Husband

From Reddit User SuperForm3G: “Fresh off a breakup on campus, match with this really good looking girl who is talking pure filth. Obviously, I’m just an idiot with a hurt heart so I don’t question much, head over to her place a few days later. She insisted I come over on a certain day at X:XX o’clock. Usually, I would’ve been sketched out but it was the middle of the day on a BIG 10 campus what exactly could go THAT south?

Half an hour in her husband came home. I was being used in a revenge plot. I pretty much just froze and he started screaming at her in a language I did not speak and she got of bed and did the same. It was at an apartment slightly off-campus where a lot of students lived so I guess I just assumed she had a roommate that wasn’t home.

Never assume.

I just basically embraced the chaos grabbed my shit as fast as I could and high-tailed it out of there. I can only assume it was intentional based on the specific meet-up, but maybe it was poor luck. Either way just talk to the cute girl at the coffee shop it’s much better than apps.“

Punch Bowl Gone Wrong

From Reddit User CleverDragon1: “I went on a tinder date several months ago around October and it went really well. The girl had a job, wasn’t crazy, and was cute so we decided to have a second date. The only thing was that the second date was at her thanksgiving party so she could introduce me to her friends and family which I thought was a bit too early. Anyways, I didn’t have anything planned that day so I decided to go.

My job was to make the jungle juice for the party and it consisted of the usual Everclear, Hawaiian Punch, lemonade powder, and ice combo I’ve used throughout college. It worked wonders and everyone got really drunk.

Near the end of the party, my date and her friends told me I did an amazing job on the drink. My date also mentioned that she really liked the “fruit” I added into there and that everyone at the party was trying to get some.

For some reason, That did not sit well with drunk me so I headed over to the alcohol canister to investigate.

I grabbed my trusty ladle and started scraping the bottom of the canisters and on one of the ladles, I found some chunks of meat and pieces of ramen. That’s when I realized that someone puked in the jungle juice.”

Cats and Dogs

From Reddit User Reavesfilm: “Matched with a cute girl who seemed to have all the same nerdy hobbies as I did… so we set up a date at a bar close to my place. We had a GREAT conversation over text, so I assumed it would go the same in person… boy was I wrong. She barely said a single word, even with my prompting her with conversation-starting questions… and finally, she goes ‘you’re a dog person aren’t you?’ I blinked a little confused and just said, ‘yeah?’ And she goes, ‘yeah I could tell, you’re way too excitable and I’m a cat person.’

I mean, fine? We can like different animals right? But THEN she goes onnnnnn and on about how she’s just like a cat and how me being a dog just wouldn’t work. From then on out anything we talked about would lead back to her = cat and me = dog… it got WEIRD. I finished my beer and told her I had to be up early (I didn’t) and left.

I still don’t know how the great text convos led to THAT but hey.. what do I know, I’m just a dumb dog.”

Matched With My BFF’s Fiance

From Reddit User Amym2001: “Matched with my BFF’s fiance after the engagement party. I did not swipe right. I took a screenshot and asked my friend what she wanted me to do. She asked me to swipe right to see if he was active. I did and he messaged me asking to hook up. I told him off. He still wanted to hook up. I gave her all the screenshots. He uninvited me from the wedding because he was certain I would embarrass him. He was correct. Screenshots of everything and lost my BFF because I don’t play that. I was uninvited to the wedding. The marriage lasted 18 months.

I wouldn’t sleep with my friend’s fiance, nor would I pretend that he wasn’t a jerk. That’s why the friendship ended.

She was from a culture that required marriage before children. She was desperate for a baby and thought he was her last chance.

He was running for a public office and wanted the smiling wife and cute baby.

Yes. They both used each other.

Yes. They had a baby.

No. He did not get elected.”

Catfished Tinder Horror Story: Went on a Date with Friends

From Reddit User 20thHokage: “I matched with this super cute girl on Tinder. We messaged back and forth for a few days. Didn’t see any red flags, we just liked the same things, and seemed like we clicked very well so we decided to meet up at a restaurant for our first date. She told me to walk in and look for a woman in a red dress. To give you some context, I don’t really do this very often so I was pretty nervous once I pulled up. I double-checked everything: Hair? Check. Breath? Check. Nothing in my teeth? Check.

So I get down and walk into the restaurant and I started looking for her. The hostess offered to seat me somewhere but I declined and said with a smirk ‘my date is waiting for me it’s okay.’ So I continued and walked in looking for her. I couldn’t seem to find her, but as soon as I turned a corner I saw a table full of my boys laughing their butts off and recording my reaction to the moment I realized I have been catfished and been flirting with the boys for the past week…”

Social Catfish is Here to Help You with Your Tinder Horror Stories

At Social Catfish, we want to help you verify the identities of those who might seem suspicious to you. If you have their name, email address, phone number, social media username, or image, you can reverse search and see who the suspected person was that you’ve been in contact with after reading about Tinder horror stories this Halloween.